i think there are a lot of choices about embodying and/or displaying queerness beyond identity politics or hiding. there’s a place i have found for myself only very recently.
to preface this with some background. i came out initially as bisexual in high school. probably when i was 15. it is hard to remember how extensively i was out. i was definitely writing about it in my journal. i was definitely arguing with my parents about it. i was definitely hanging out with a lot of queers. i definitely made out with a lot of girls in high school.
my first year of college, i got involved with the queer group and went to my first queer bar. in bangor maine no less! i went on a birthday date with this girl when my boyfriend was in mexico. by 2000 i was out to most and dating a girl for the first time. while i experimented in high school… fishnets, plastic skirts, piercing, cutting, making out with boys and girls, this really tapered off my senior year of high school. i became increasingly political and decided political expression was more important than personal expression(!)
i grew up in a political household, commie parents, started my first organization in 5th grade. but it took on new dimensions. and in the realm of mostly male, mostly straight activists, i basically gave up a lot of myself to prove my priorities. i think this was a massive mistake. because caring about stuff meant passing. it meant not making ‘the people’ uncomfortable by my eccentricities. also code for my queerness.
i eventually left politics. too much bullshit. to many people i knew sexually assaulted by activists. too much talk and action and little confrontation of fears and prejudices that prevent community. the feeling that i couldn’t mesh my political life with my life, my family life. the feeling of hypocrisy.
i eventually ended up working as a secretary in an incredibly hetero-normative hospital. this combined with my girlfriend’s semi self-hating relationship to her queerness and queer presentation led to me really passing. finally losing much of myself there. it took a good 2 years to start to recover.
i was at idapalooza in 2008 and again in 2009. ida is queer land in tennessee near short mountain, a radical faerie community. each year they host a weeklong queer music festival. it was while there that somethings began to come together for me. my relationship w g., working w nayland. working for visual aids, having so many queer teachers in my mfa program (learning simultaneously about contemporary photography, my practice/life/self, and radical queer NYC history), etc.
i had this amazing conversation with this person at Ida. we were talking about family and community. he grew up with radical parents and his father is gay (i’m not sure how he identified when his son was younger). his parents hated the culture of his grandparents so they moved him faraway from them to Texas. he didn’t know them until he requested to meet them. he grew up really isolated with just him and his parents.
we began talking about what it means to strike out on a path different (dramatically or slightly?) from the life of our parents. and there is a big difference between a path chosen or a new path forced… or perhaps then it is the choice regarding what you were forced to change in your life.
my father grew up in a middle class, educated jewish family in brooklyn. i gather that my grandparents had fairly high expectations for the children. though it seems with a lot of room to determine what that means given that one became an artist (my grandma was an artist as well), one an acupuncturist, one a labor organizer. my father began school at city college, studying astronomy, but dropped out halfway through to work full time protesting the vietnam war (with the youth wing of the communist party, the web dubois club.) it is complicated what ended up happening… but i would say that the vision was to NOT do what my grandparents had done. but what would that look like? i don’t think my father really had much of a vision for a radically different path. which makes it really easy especially once you have children or face poverty or trauma… i mean perhaps these things could also spur a radically new way but it is also equally or even moreso possible that there will be a default into the comfort of what had come before.
my mother was one if 13 children from an extremely poor farming/coal mining family in central west Virginia. she along with half my aunts and uncles fled the lands of silent coal shafts and dead industry for ohio. to work in a factory! all my uncles have professions- mechanics, factory workers, rental car managers. almost all my aunts are wives and mothers. my mom and aunt j. are the only two to finish high school (many quit at 6th, 8th grade). they are also the only two women with professions. my mom is a housekeeper (until she retires thankfully from a thankless job next spring!) and my aunt j. is a medical assistant. i am fairly certain that my siblings and i are the only cousins to go to college. fairly certain that i am the first on that side to get a master’s degree.
anyways, my mom had her first kid at 21. was chased out of the house by her husband who was wielding a shotgun, took my 10 month old sister and never went back. she raised my sister for eight years alone. til she met my dad.
it is sad to me to see my mom who is definitely a rural woman at heart… with no way back. stuck. as so many women who were not raised to guide their own way. to make the choices for a life of our own. i see myself at times not sticking up enough for a life i could love. i understand. especially if nothing ever showed you that you would have a better life if you fought for it. and even moreso when you have to fight just to survive.
i think it is not enough to not want what came before. you have to develop a sense of what you do want, a very personal idea of what you want (even if it is bound up in larger political spiritual etc ideas) and find the ways to commit your self to it. fight for it, make it, not just survive it.
so i swear this circles back to where i began this post.
when i was at ida, i met radical faeries from short mountain. i also began researching radical fairie land once i returned home. a lot of these lands have existed in some form for thirty years or more! then there is lesbian land and queer land and feminist land. many created around the time that my father was choosing something else, when so many were choosing something other than what came before. but my father had a lot going for him. a hetero normative culture to welcome him and his relationships. whiteness. education.
queer people did not have a cultural space given over or as a given. it had to be created. it doesn’t mean that all hets have it all or that white people do or men but that there is a privilege there that allows easier movement or taking up of space. it also makes it easier to find or make what you want. if you don’t choose something radically different then it can be easier to find your place and comfort.
even now with so much lgbt representation in mainstream pop culture. who does that really represent? who is that providing space for? the class nature of the L Word is appalling. where are our multivalent sexualities and sexual practices and complex representations that could start to get at the complexity that is queer?
i see another road around identity. it is not so much about identity politics as it is about family and tribe.
wearing signifiers on our bodies has been the way for queer visibility since early closeted times. not to show our queerness to straight people but to find each other! (buzz cuts, mullets, earrings, hankies, etc)
i used to downplay dress and expression. but i’ve come to realize that it may help me live more the life i want to live.
if i feel more loved, supported, challenged, moved, inspired etc by queerness then the best way to find it is to display my own queerness. it of course is not clear cut. there are infinite ways to be or display queer. and not all queer people are my people. not all straight people are excluded. but i have found at times that it can be really hard to find ‘my people.’ if i am passing as straight, it is all that less likely. and it isn’t easy because i am often coded as more feminine so i have to find ways like piercings and shaved hair and butch touches to put it out there.
and i decided his simultaneous to wanting to make collective queer space/land. to live off of. make art. hold gatherings. build the life i want.
it is just something i’ve found might help me collect those around me that i want to work with in life. at least it is the place, queerness, where i’ve found the most.
and far better the way to ‘my people’ than to this mythology of ‘the people’